Skip to content
Made Better With Butter

Recipes / Desserts · Holidays

Classic Apple Pie

ATK's classic apple pie with Washington apples — Red Delicious and Fuji for sweet, Granny Smith for tart — baked hot on the bottom rack so the crust stays crisp.

Prep
30 min
Cook
About 1 hr, plus cooling
Serves
8 slices
A double-crust apple pie with a deep golden, sugar-flecked top, cooling on foil beside a wire rack

What we changed

Changes from the America's Test Kitchen original. Where it came from

  • Washington apples for the sweet half. 1 lb Red Delicious and 1 lb Fuji in place of the 2 lb of McIntosh. The Granny Smiths stay as written for the tartness.

This is America’s Test Kitchen’s classic apple pie. The trick is the apples: a sweet variety and a tart one together. ATK uses McIntosh for the sweet side. We use Washington apples instead, a pound each of Red Delicious and Fuji, with the Granny Smiths as written.

The other thing worth following is the oven. It starts very hot with a preheated sheet on the bottom rack, then steps down twice so the filling cooks through without burning the top. That’s what keeps the bottom crust from going soggy.

In the fall we buy apples by the case at the farmers market and make all the fall treats we can. That has meant apple pies for a few occasions and a lot of chunky applesauce, much of it given away to friends.

Three and a half pounds of apples is a lot of peeling. We use an old-school crank peeler that suctions to the counter and peels, cores and slices each apple in one pass, which makes the job quick and a little fun.

The pie in a glass pie plate with half cut away, showing layers of apple slices and juice pooled in the empty half of the dish
A red cast-metal apple peeler suctioned to a granite counter, holding a peeled and spiral-cut apple with a strip of red peel curling off the blade
The crank peeler peels, cores and slices in one go.
A bowl of apple pie topped with whipped cream, with a spoon resting in it
With whipped cream.

Make it

Makes 8 slices

Ingredients

Filling

Crust

To serve

  1. Put a rimmed baking sheet on the lowest oven rack and heat the oven to 500°F. The sheet needs the full preheat to get hot.
  2. Peel, core and slice the apples. A crank peeler that suctions to the counter does all three in one pass, cutting each apple into a continuous spiral; cut the spiral into pieces.
  3. In a big bowl, toss all the apples with the ¾ cup sugar, flour, lemon juice, zest, salt, nutmeg and cinnamon.
  4. Roll the top crust into a 12-inch round.
  5. Tip the apples into the dough-lined plate and mound them a little higher in the center.
  6. Lay the top crust over, trim, seal and crimp the edge, then cut four vents.
  7. Brush the top with egg white and scatter the last tablespoon of sugar over it.
  8. Set the pie on the hot baking sheet and drop the oven to 425°F. Bake until the top is golden, about 25 minutes.
  9. Turn the baking sheet around and drop the oven to 375°F. Bake until the juices bubble through the vents and the crust is deep brown, 30 to 35 minutes more.
  10. Move the pie to a wire rack and let it cool to room temperature before cutting.

Good to know

  • ATK's original uses 2 lb McIntosh as the sweet apple. The point is the mix of sweet and tart, so use whatever good sweet apples you have alongside the Granny Smiths.
  • Cut it warm and the juices run into the bottom of the dish. Cooling it all the way lets the filling set.
  • Keeps at room temperature, wrapped tightly in foil, for up to 2 days.
  • The hot sheet on the bottom rack catches drips and crisps the bottom crust. Line it with foil for easy cleanup.