Skip to content
Made Better With Butter

Recipes / Soups · Holidays

Split Pea and Ham Soup

ATK's split pea soup with smoked ham hocks in the long simmer, triple the butter, two pounds of ham in real chunks, and no salt until you've tasted the ham.

Prep
20 min
Cook
About 2¾ hr
Serves
8 servings
Pot
7-qt Dutch oven or stockpot
A large stainless pot of thick green split pea soup on the stove, dotted with diced carrot, onion, celery and pink chunks of ham

What we changed

Changes from the America's Test Kitchen original. Where it came from

  • Triple the butter. 6 tablespoons instead of 2. Richer base for the onions and a silkier soup.
  • Smoked ham hocks (or pork shanks from the butcher) go in for the long simmer. The bone and collagen give the soup the body a ham steak alone can't. It's the hambone ATK skipped, back in.
  • Double the ham steak, cut into chunks and added late. 2 pounds instead of 1, cubed instead of shredded, so everyone gets real hunks of ham.
  • No salt until the ham is in and you've tasted it. Hocks, bacon and ham bring plenty. Salting the onions up front, as ATK does, can blow up the soup.
  • Roughly twice the simmer. The peas break down completely while the carrots and celery, added late, still hold their shape. The bacon keeps it smoky.

This is America’s Test Kitchen’s split pea and ham soup. In place of the traditional hambone, ATK simmers a ham steak and a few slices of bacon in the water, and the unsoaked peas soak up all that pork flavor.

We put the bone back in. Smoked ham hocks go into the pot (pork shanks from the butcher when we can’t find hocks) for a long, slow simmer. They give the soup a body the ham steak can’t. We double the ham steak and cut it into chunks instead of shredding it, so every bowl has real pieces of meat. And we triple the butter, of course. The older ATK Family Cookbook version also uses smoked hocks.

The simmer runs about twice as long as ATK’s, until the peas have completely broken down. The carrots and celery go in late, so they’re still chunks when the soup is done. The bacon gives the whole pot its smoky flavor.

Around the holidays, leftover ham chunks up nicely and goes right in. One warning: between the hocks, the bacon and the ham, salt can ruin this. Don’t add any until the ham is in and you’ve tasted it.

A stainless stockpot on an induction burner, the soup still thin and pale with chunks of ham, diced carrot, celery and onion
Partway through. The peas haven't broken down yet.
A partly carved smoked ham on a cutting board beside a long slicing knife, a plate of ham slices, and trimmed fat and skin on a red board with a carving fork
Leftover holiday ham works too.
A shallow bowl piled with bite-size cubes of pink ham, a few with browned edges
Cut it into chunks, not shreds.
The shank end of a ham with its bone showing, surrounded by scraps of meat and fat on a cutting board, with plates of sliced and cubed ham behind it

Make it

Makes 8 servings

1x is about 5 quarts. Fits a 7-quart Dutch oven or stockpot.

Ingredients

  1. Melt the butter in a large Dutch oven or stockpot over medium-high heat until the foaming dies down.
  2. Add the onion and cook, stirring often, until soft, 3 to 4 minutes. No salt yet.
  3. Add the garlic and cook until fragrant, about 30 seconds.
  4. Add the ham hocks or shanks, bacon, split peas, thyme and bay leaves, then enough water to cover them.
  5. Bring to a simmer over high heat, stirring so the peas don't settle and stick.
  6. Turn the heat to low, cover and simmer about 2 hours, stirring every 20 to 30 minutes and adding water if the meat pokes out. The peas should be breaking down and the hocks or shanks tender.
  7. Lift out the hocks or shanks and set them aside. Their meat has given its flavor to the soup, so it doesn't go back in.
  8. Stir in the ham chunks, carrots and celery. Cover and simmer until the vegetables are tender but still hold their shape and the peas have fully broken down, 30 to 40 minutes.
  9. Fish out and discard the bacon slices, thyme sprigs and bay leaves.
  10. Taste it now that all the ham is in. Only then add salt, if it needs any, and pepper. Serve.

Good to know

  • Salt is the one way to ruin this. Between the hocks, bacon and ham it can easily go too far, so add none until the ham is in and you've tasted it.
  • Around the holidays, leftover baked ham cubes up well and can stand in for the ham steak. It's often saltier still, so taste before any salt goes in.
  • Thick, broken-down peas scorch easily on the bottom of the pot. Keep stirring through the long simmer.
  • Adding the carrots and celery late is what keeps them in chunks. In for the whole simmer, they turn to mush.
  • The spent hock or shank meat is a treat for the dog.
  • It thickens as it sits. Thin it with water when you reheat.